Back to questions
NOVEMBERFinal

CASE STUDY: 2 ABOUT THE COMPANY ABC Agri Limited (herein after referred as 'the company') is a listed company, engaged in the manufacture of fertilisers and pesticides and markets its products through dealer network. The role of agriculture in the Indian economy is of utmost importance and the Government monitors the production and distribution of fertilisers across India. The Government also provides subsidy to the fertiliser manufacturers based on sales made to the ultimate end users who are the farmers. The subsidy amount is computed based on the nutrient content in the fertilizers. The Company has a strong Research & Development (R & D) team which is equipped with state of the art facilities. The R & D team is associated with multiple international crop research agencies and agriculture universities involved in the study of climatic changes, soil health testing, changes in cropping patterns and study of molecules enriching the agriculture yields, etc. ISSUES NOTICED More than 80% of the raw material requirements are imported by the Company, which includes rock phosphate & acids. Due to the war between Russia & Ukraine, there has been a manifold increase in the raw material prices and shipping costs which the Company is unable to pass on to the customers. In addition to steep increase in prices, the US $ conversion rates have also contributed to the increase in raw material costs, which required close monitoring of currency movements and focus on foreign currency hedge. PROPOSALS BEFORE THE COMPANY The company intends to introduce new-age fertilizers & pesticides with the help of the R & D team. R & D team assesses the performance of the new products in test environment. On satisfactory completion of the trials, the product combinations are released to the business & legal teams for necessary regulatory approvals and launching of the products. While the R & D team is coming up with new product portfolio, the marketing team have come up with an idea of marketing these new age products through e-commerce and direct delivery channels to the farmers. Prior to the launch of these products the marketing team would like to carry out a survey to understand the farmer's expectation, present gaps in meeting such expectation, market demand, regulatory compliances, supply chain challenges, etc., and appointed an external survey agency to carry out market research and give its recommendations. SURVEY FINDINGS The following survey findings were shared with the marketing team for taking necessary mitigation steps prior to the launch of new products : • The end customers are primarily farmers, who lack awareness of using mobile apps. and place direct orders on the mobile app. • The company may have to make investments, in supply chain & logistics, by way of setting up additional warehouses and procurement of trucks and delivery vans at remote locations and would require compliance with statutory requirements including licenses etc. • Branding of the new products via e-commerce channels is a challenging exercise. Farmers are not aware of the new product properties & its applications. • Company need to invest in IT infrastructure for application development/support "e-commerce portal". • Company to recruit additional manpower for demonstration and delivery of the products at the door step of the farmers. RISK MANAGEMENT BY THE COMPANY The Company has a robust ERM framework in place, which includes complete documentation of Risk Registers, establishing Risk Management Committee and Operational Risk Committees, risk scores, monitoring tools etc. covering Strategic and Operational activities. All activities of the company are systematically segregated into various functions starting from procurement to marketing supported by strategic and back office teams. The risks are classified into controllable and un-controllable risks. The inherent risk faced by the company is primarily monsoon. During the average monsoon period, the company achieves the production & sales targets. During monsoon failure scenario, the sales volumes reduces by almost 50%. The Board and the Leadership team are aware of the inherent risks faced by the company, against which mitigation procedures are put in place. There is also a strong team of Internal audit, which is aligned with the ERM framework of the Company. The internal audits are carried out based on the risk matrix to ensure key risks are integrated with audit execution. On a regular basis, the risks identified during process are shared by the Chief Risk Officer (CRO) with the internal audit team, who in turn considers the same during the planning and execution of various functional audits. SIGNIFICANT RISKS HIGHLIGHTED FOR MITIGATION During the presentation to the Risk Management Committee, CRO highlighted the following significant risks, against which mitigation procedures were also deliberated. • Significant volatility in the Raw material prices • Non-availability of ships for importing raw materials • Foreign currency fluctuations leading to high input costs • Storage space constraints within manufacturing locations • Lack of adequate gear to employees handling hazardous chemicals • High talent attrition. • Trade-marks/patent infringement by competitors • Finished products were awaiting sale due to delayed monsoons. • Over dues on account of monsoon failures. • Unauthorised access & hacking of the system Multiple Choice Questions: Choose the most appropriate answer from the given options.

Sub-questions (9)

question_2.12 MarksMCQ

The gap between the inherent risk and residual risk in the above ERM Environment :

A

(A) Shows the strength of the controls and is known as control score.

B

(B) Shows the level of Risk appetite and is known as Risk score.

C

(C) Shows the strength of controls and is known as Risk score.

D

(D) Explains controllable risks and the probability of their occurrence.

question_2.22 MarksMCQ

The operational risk is an overarching concept inter-related with

A

(A) Risks relating to production activities

B

(B) Risks relating to both production and maintenance activities

C

(C) Risks related to all activities and not restricted to production

D

(D) Risks related to production, maintenance, human resources which are having financial impact.

question_2.32 MarksMCQ

The risk monitoring tools to track the progress of risk management using qualitative assessment of probability and impact of risk :

A

(A) Risk Event Map

B

(B) Flow Charts and Risk Maps

C

(C) Risk Heat Maps

D

(D) Risk Score Cards

question_2.42 MarksMCQ

A company's decision to launch new products, through e-commerce portal, which is outside its existing core competency is BEST known as :

A

(A) Uncertainty

B

(B) Ambiguity

C

(C) Complexity

D

(D) Volality

question_2.52 MarksMCQ

Every listed company normally constitutes Risk Management Committee. Among the various responsibilities of the committee, which one is not required to be carried out by the Risk Management Committee.

A

(A) Discuss the risk strategies on both aggregate basis and on individual basis.

B

(B) Oversee that the management has robust processes to ensure adherence to the risk policies approved by the Board.

C

(C) Risk Committee to discuss the agenda matters coming up for Board Meeting.

D

(D) Review and approve the mitigation processes in place annually.

question_2.65 MarksShort Answer

Document the responsible function in the organisation and a mitigation procedure for any of the five significant risks presented by the CRO to the Risk Management Committee, covered in the above case.

question_2.75 MarksShort Answer

The Board seeks your advise, with respect to the disclosure in the Annual Report relating to Risks and Concerns of the business, based on the Case Study.

question_2.8(a)3 MarksShort Answer

Elucidate, how the risks and its mitigation procedures are considered for carrying out an effective internal audit, by the audit team.

question_2.8(b)2 MarksShort Answer

For the first two commercial risks identified by the CRO, explain how the internal audit team can carry out a risk based audit to address the specific risk.

november_2022_paper_6A_risk_management | Kartavvya